Saturday, December 28, 2024

Conversation III - The problem with 3 space




Which means light, as a wave, is analog when in free space but transitions into digital when striking the screen because said photons are absorbed by electrons but this absorption cannot be accomplished unless the transfer of energy via the photon must be properly formatted in order for the electron to absorb the photon as needs warrant. This is why this experiment exhibits the unique characteristics of light in such a profound and elegant way.

Thus begins Conversation III - The problem with 3 space.



Gemini understands the double slit experiment to the nth degree as an scientific and intellectual construct but the ability for the system to image the experiment correctly, not so much as the AI lives in  2 space similar to Abbot's Flatland, making it truly difficult for Gemini to intuitively understand the physical configuration of the experiment.



The 2D conundrum also applies to 3D graphics projected onto the flat screen of a computer as the screen is 2D and the 3 space environment is projected onto it, The inherent distortion of a 3D scene is eliminated if orthographic projection is used instead of perspective.

To whit.



Gemini's take on the double slit


This is Gemini's 1st take.


Here's the 2nd.

Gemini's analysis of this 3D representation of the double slit ...



Yours truly did the deed with Midjourey. Same result, awesome graphic but not right.


So ... 

To that end, the notorious double slit diagram is the star of the show to see if an AI imaging environment different from Imagen 3 could do the deed. The answer remains no even though MJ perfectly described the science behind the diagram sent and I quote: A diagram showing the double-slit experiment, which demonstrates the wave-like behavior of light. The diagram includes a screen with two slits, and a graph showing the interference pattern of light waves passing through the slits. 

End result: The essence of the DS diagram, 3D or otherwise, could not be accurately duplicated by various AIs in 3D which means ... this is a really difficult problem for AI to solve. 

Gemini

No comments: